Jeremiah's self fulfilling prophesy

Anyone checking out Jeremiah Owyang's social media news digest?  It's pretty damn good.  A few weeks ago Jeremiah stated he thinks analysts are morphing into journalists as they have closer connections with the industry players and he's working hare to prove the point on his own blog.

Like IdaRose, I'm not sure it's true but reading Jeremiah's stuff is very educational.

Comments

  1. Loring WirbelAugust 20, 2008 at 8:54 AM

    Not to be catty (hell, blogs serve useful purposes), but one difference between analyst (or any other type of blogger) and journalist is that the former has no copy-editor, thus has an opening sentence that says "I know have confirmation" rather than "I now have confirmation." Yes, that's petty, and yes, as media companies get more hollowed out, they will have fewer copy editors and will resemble bloggers more and more, but there is indeed something to be said for an actual maintained infrastructure behind the word torrent. And one can still sense a certain shallowness behind TechCrunch, Engadget, Gizmodo, and analyst-news-blogs, as compared to true news sites.

    ReplyDelete
  2. John BlylerAugust 23, 2008 at 12:34 PM

    Agree with Loring. Copy editing - and appreciating the need for such - are a differentiator. That said, I would note that a few journalist (at least those with a technical background) have begun doing analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lou CoveyAugust 25, 2008 at 2:10 PM

    John, that goes back to Jeremiah's original posit: that through blogging analysts are becoming reporters and reporters are becoming analysts.

    ReplyDelete
  4. John BlylerAugust 26, 2008 at 3:23 AM

    Hi Lou. Well, through blogging, yes ... But I meant in a more substantial way, i.e., with access to hard numbers, doing the actual analysis based on those numbers, performing sponsored surveys of users and compiling results, even paying for industry recognized analysts for help. This is one enterprise that is beginning to show results for us (Chip Design), at any rate.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I'm old and you are not. That's good thing.

Image
I turned 64 this year and have been on the receiving end of scams and offers related to social security, dementia and Medicare for weeks now. I'm also getting offered senior discounts without asking. None of that has bothered me as much as getting dismissed because I'm no longer in my 30s (which bothered me as much when I was in my 20s). Today, however I had a revelation and I'm feeling much better about my age. I was doing a session with the marketing team for a small business back by telephone and was in the process of breaking down their preconceived notions about communication when the youngest member of the team asked me, "How do you know this is what our customers are thinking?" "Because I've been doing this for 40 years," I replied. "Oh." She replied.  Then one of the business owners, well into his 70s asks, "Wait a minute. You said you've been doing this fo r 40 years. How old are you?" "I'm 64....
Read more

Speaking of ethics in sponsored content...

Image
An article today in Forbes on ethics in sponsored content  brought back memories of our recent discussions regarding UBM Tech's methodology changes and the larger discussion about whether corporations can be expected to deliver ethical content. The article points out that Edelman has posted their own set of ethics regarding sponsored content that remarkably mirrors Footwasher Media's position:  That it isn't PR or advertising.  It's something different from what most corporate advocates practice and it must be, by nature, ethical or it loses all value. Many people in the news business have taken ethical standards for granted.  They seem to believe that they are intertwined with the genesis of journalism itself.  It isn't true.  The news business, supported by advertising began in the 1700s with Benjamin Franklin's founding of the Pennsylvania Gazette , but the separation of advertising from editorial did not appear until th...
Read more

Why you don't (or do) like social media, Part Three

Image
When you boil down attitudes toward and execution of social media practices, it's all about leadership.  Real leadership, not the popular definition that rises from the horrific misinterpretation  of Geoffrey Moore's book, Crossing the Chasm .  Let me explain that reference a bit more in depth first. Moore stated fairly simply that for a technology company to be successful, it must attain the perception of leadership in a market niche.  The misinterpretation of that concept is what screws up the marketing for so many companies.  Moore's statement was an indicator of success and a strategy, not a tactic.  If you are the perceived market niche leader, Moore explains, THEN you know you successfully crossed the chasm.  Therefore your marketing strategy must revolve around developing the perception of leadership.  However, most companies believe that saying you are a leader in your marketing documents, even when you are clearl...
Read more